The Widening Gap Between Prime and Secondary Commercial Property
Updated: Nov 11
Melbourne's CBD office vacancy rate sits close to 19 per cent, the highest of any Australian capital. That number suggests a market in trouble; however, the strongest buildings are leasing and lifting rents while older secondary stock struggles to keep tenants. For investors, understanding the differences between prime and secondary property is critical to their success.
At Key Change Finance, our background in private and business banking means we spend a lot of time looking at how lenders view different commercial assets, and the lens they apply to prime and secondary property is very different. Here is what the data shows about the gap, why headline vacancy can mislead, and what it means for investors considering value-add or repositioning plays.
What Is the Prime and Secondary Yield Gap?
A yield is the annual net income from a property as a percentage of its value. Because investors price risk into yields, secondary assets typically trade at higher yields than prime ones, reflecting weaker tenant demand, shorter leases, higher capital expenditure needs and greater vacancy risk.
What is unusual now is the size of the gap. Knight Frank reported a spread of 97 basis points in mid 2025, which it described as the widest since the first quarter of 2016. By Q4 2025 it had grown to 107 basis points, a 10-year high. Over the same period, prime yields themselves have moved out as investors repriced the whole sector. Urban Property's Q1 2026 research recorded average metropolitan office yields of 7.5 per cent for prime and 9.15 per cent for secondary, and expected the spread to keep widening.
Yields also vary by location within the prime market. Knight Frank's mid 2025 analysis put the average prime yield in the East of the CBD at 6.3 per cent, compared with 6.7 per cent in the West and Docklands and 7.6 per cent in Flagstaff.
Why Headline Vacancy Can Mislead
Vacancy depends partly on who is measuring it. Knight Frank reports Melbourne CBD vacancy at 18.9 per cent, while JLL's Q2 2026 research put the headline rate at 20.5 per cent. Both agree the market is oversupplied, but neither describes the experience of a prime tower in the Eastern Core or a well-located building in Southbank.
The more useful question is where tenants are choosing to go. Knight Frank's data shows prime net face rents averaging $773 per square metre in Q2 2026, up 5.2 per cent over the year, even as vacancy has stayed high. Eastern Core prime face rents rose 10.4 per cent in 2025, and Southbank has recorded lower vacancy than most CBD precincts. Meanwhile, secondary stock saw negative net absorption through 2025, and Urban Property has pointed to a growing risk of obsolescence for older buildings as tenants trade up to better space.
In other words, a significant part of the vacancy problem is concentrated in buildings that are no longer what tenants want, rather than a uniform decline across the market.
Where Might Opportunities Sit?
On the prime side, supply is thinning. Knight Frank expects no meaningful speculative CBD office supply for several years once 435 Bourke Street completes later this year, and JLL expects the supply pipeline to fall to its lowest level in more than two decades after Q3 2026. If demand keeps recovering, that sets up stronger rental performance for well-located prime assets. Knight Frank also expects incentives, currently averaging 48.1 per cent in the prime market, to approach their peak and stabilise through 2027.
On the secondary side, higher yields can look attractive, but they are compensation for real risks. Repositioning a secondary building through refurbishment, change of use or better amenity is where investors can create value, but it relies on accurate costings, realistic leasing assumptions and funding that allows time for the work to pay off. Incentives averaging close to half of face rent mean the effective rent a landlord collects can sit well below the headline figure.
Transaction evidence is thin. Knight Frank recorded $286 million of Melbourne CBD office transactions in the first half of 2026, and JLL noted only one CBD office sale above $5 million in Q2 2026. With so little evidence, valuations can lag, and yield expansion is still possible. JLL expects some decompression through the rest of 2026, with liquidity possibly improving after November's state election.
How Lenders See Prime and Secondary Assets
The prime and secondary divide shows up in lending, not just leasing. Lenders generally assess commercial property on its income, the strength and length of its leases and the quality of the asset, and they tend to apply lower loan-to-value ratios and stricter conditions where the security is weaker. A secondary building with short lease terms, high vacancy or obvious capital expenditure needs may be assessed more cautiously than a prime asset with a long lease to a strong tenant. Valuers also tend to be conservative where recent sales evidence is limited.
That has two practical implications. The first is that investors should expect to contribute more equity on secondary assets and plan for valuation risk. The second is that structure is important: the right lender, term, interest-only period and covenants for the asset can make the difference between a repositioning that works and one that stalls. Specifics vary by lender and by property, so it pays to take advice before committing to a contract.
For investors, the lesson is that Melbourne's headline vacancy hides a two-speed market. Prime and well-located assets are attracting tenants, while older secondary buildings are facing weaker demand, higher incentives and tougher lending. Opportunities exist at both ends, but they carry very different risks and need different finance structures.
A market that looks weak on the surface can contain some of its best opportunities, and some of its most expensive mistakes. The difference usually comes down to the quality of the asset, the strength of the numbers and the structure of the finance. If you are considering a commercial investment in Melbourne, whether a prime asset or a repositioning play, the team at Key Change Finance can help you understand how lenders will view it before you commit.
Get in touch with us to talk through your plans and your funding options.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the yield difference between prime and secondary office property in Melbourne?
According to Knight Frank's Q4 2025 report, the average prime yield in the Melbourne CBD was 6.76 per cent and the average secondary yield was 7.82 per cent, a spread of 107 basis points, which it described as a 10-year high. Prime yields have since softened, to an average of 7.02 per cent in Q2 2026. Yields vary by precinct and asset quality.
What is the Melbourne CBD office vacancy rate?
Knight Frank reports Melbourne CBD office vacancy at 18.9 per cent in its latest report, while JLL's Q2 2026 research put the headline rate at 20.5 per cent. The difference reflects measurement methods. Both indicate the market is oversupplied, but conditions vary widely by building quality and precinct.
Why is secondary office property struggling in Melbourne?
Tenants have been moving towards higher-quality, better-located buildings. Knight Frank recorded net absorption of 40,070 square metres in prime stock during 2025 but negative 10,595 square metres in secondary stock. Older buildings also face greater obsolescence risk, higher incentives and tougher conditions from lenders and valuers.
Are there opportunities in Melbourne's secondary office market?
Potentially, but they come with real risk. Higher yields on secondary assets can reward investors who reposition buildings through refurbishment, change of use or improved amenity. Success depends on accurate costings, realistic leasing assumptions and appropriate funding. Weak transaction evidence and high incentives mean investors should be cautious and take advice before buying.
Will Melbourne's office supply pipeline tighten?
Both Knight Frank and JLL expect it to. Knight Frank expects effectively no meaningful speculative CBD office supply for several years after 435 Bourke Street completes later this year, and JLL expects under-construction stock to fall to its lowest level in over two decades after Q3 2026. If demand continues to recover, reduced supply could support rents for well-located prime assets.
Is it harder to finance secondary commercial property?
Generally, yes. Lenders tend to apply lower loan-to-value ratios and tighter conditions to assets with weaker leasing, shorter lease terms or capital expenditure needs. Investors should expect to contribute more equity and plan for conservative valuations. Terms vary between lenders, so it is worth comparing options before committing to a purchase.





Comments